Eat the pencil
Andrew bets Gavin he could eat 50X hamburgers in 10 hours, some time after losing that he pitches to Gavin he could eat 25X double hamburgers in 10 hours. They set up this challenge moments after Andrew had discussed his theory on eating a pencil. So while setting up this new bet, Geoff pitches that if Andrew loses this new burger challenge he must eat a leadless pencil. Andrew fails the 2nd burger challenge so he contacts some law students to get out of eating a pencil. On the day the members of F**kface are going to come to a ruling on the pencil Geoff can't make it, so they reschedule. Andrew turns up at the original time and hosts his solo court case. At the new time the others are angry with Andrew for this. In the end Eric contacts 3 judges for their ruling and they all agree. Andrew must eat the pencil. In the end Andrew admits that he lost the bet and did agree to eat the pencil, but to this day he has not eaten a pencil.
Eating a pencil discussion: S1. E12. TIME: 00:32:33 Episode link
Pencil payment pitched: S1. E12. TIME: 00:36:26 Episode link
Andrew agrees: S1. E12. TIME: 00:43:26 Episode link
Panton defense group: S1. E16. TIME: 00:05:14 Episode link
Andrews solo court case: S1. E17. TIME: 00:02:03 Episode link
3 judge ruling: S1. E18. TIME: 00:57:52 Episode link
Andrew admits he agreed: S1. E18. TIME: 01:02:31 Episode link